group critique # 2

Length: 2 -3 pages, double spaced
Due: Weds. March 16, at 8am the day of the final exam

You were provided a group presentation paper to critique. In this paper you will refute the claims made by another group using either fallacies, weaknesses, and/ or refute their argument by presenting your own claim. In this paper you are given a loose guideline to follow so that you can demonstrate the skills you have learned in class - will you choose to identify fallacies? will you identify fallacies and explore weaknesses?

The paper must be in essay format (intro, body, conclusion) In the intro you should provide me with a summary of the paper so I first and foremost know what paper you are refuting and in the conclusion I would like to have you include your opinion on the piece (was it effective despite teh flaws?)